Friday, April 12, 2013

Thoughts on the gun debate part six: A scholar's view of history.

This is going to be a short post. I want to call your attention to Steven Halbrook's lastest piece for the Fordham Law Review. He explores efforts to include a right to arms in their 1789 Declaration of the Rights of Man, and adoption of gun registration just in time for the Nazi occupation and gun confiscations.

The full article is available here. I'm going to cite (claiming fair use) a section from his conclusion.

The suggestion has been made in Supreme Court dissents in Second Amendment and firearm law cases that European models are superior to that of the United States. Similar arguments have been made in debate in Congress on bills to register and restrict firearm ownership. The historical experiences of France do not present a rosy picture for emulation.
Guarantees of the right to keep and bear arms were demanded by the Third Estate in France and were considered, but not adopted, in the French Declaration of Rights of 1789. No constitutional tradition existed in France of a right of commoners to possess arms. Without such a tradition, it appears to have been relatively easy for the French government, under the leadership of Pierre Laval, simply to decree the registration of firearms in 1935. Just five years later, France fell to Nazi Germany, which decreed the death penalty for possession of a firearm unless turned in within twenty-four hours. The 1940 armistice provided that the French authorities collaborate with the Wehrmacht, and the French police obliged by arresting gun owners and confiscating firearms. Pierre Laval returned to power and became France’s chief collaborator with Germany.
Five years of Nazi occupation occurred with the potential of the death penalty hanging over the head of every French person who refused to surrender his or her gun. That historical experience teaches two lessons about gun control that modern prohibitionists seem to ignore.
...
Modern gun prohibitionists may argue that an armed populace is of no use to prevent occupation by a foreign tyranny, and that only standing armies are of any use. Yet the French standing army proved of little use in 1940, when the German Wehrmacht smashed it in just a few weeks. True, armed French civilians could not liberate France without the help of foreign armies, but the Resistance was certainly impeded by the French gun registration policies which made it easier to confiscate firearms.
The existence of even a partially-armed populace, an unknown number of civilians who did not surrender their firearms, remained an element of uncertainty and a threat to the perceived security of the occupation forces. The Nazis were thus forced to utilize more troops and resources than they would have needed to occupy a country that was relatively more “gun free.”
Disregarding armed resistance by civilians, the sheer existence of unknown armed civilians led the Germans to expend resources and to decrease the number of forces available to fight the Allied armies. The mere existence of anonymous gun owners, even disregarding actual resistance activities, thus contributed to the anti-Nazi effort.
In short, everyone who, whether actively or passively, opposed the German occupation—from private citizens with unregistered firearms who thereby created insecurity for the occupation forces, to members of the Resistance who carried guns while committing acts of sabotage, to the members of the Allied armed forces in the great battles following the Normandy invasion—contributed to the defeat of Nazism.
To those who would discard the Second Amendment and emulate European models of firearm registration and prohibition, the historical experience of France suggests a telling lesson: Be careful what you wish for.
I urge you to go read the full article, it's an excellent explanation of the difference between European history and models and the U.S. 

Highly recommended.

31 comments:

Dragon Naturally Speaking Support said...

Hi i'm share thusme necessary website that everybody use this point so if you have got needing connected like Dragon naturally speaking support, HP Printer Offline, Brother Printer offline, Avg login, Kaspersky Login, Garmin Login, Webroot.com/Safe, Office.com/setup any time visit here and obtain the entire resolution for your error.


Dragon naturally speaking support
HP Printer Offline
Garmin Login
Webroot.com/Safe
Office.com/setup
garmin.com/express
TurboTax Support

shopify said...

3 Useful Ways to Improve Productivity at Workplace Have you ever finished your working day via feeling like you weren’t able to achieve everything on your to-do list? You must start with a free plan, a list, and a goal. However, by the end of the day, you must clarify that your to-do list is retained for a long timeframe.

shopify said...

The Pandemic outbreak has caused too much trouble for the online buyers and big vendors like Amazon. During this Covid-19, Amazon is not the only e-commerce store suffering to increase their sales, a majority of other web stores are testing their patience. Though undoubtedly, being an e-commerce store they are offering discounts and other facilities to entice people

shopify said...

8 Important Aspects to Consider For the Development of an E-Commerce Mobile Application

In this era, mobile applications are preferred by many business leaders. The reason behind the development of mobile apps for businesses is to improve your online existence with enhanced user engagement trends

John Willson said...

Cash App is one of the most using apps in US for receive and transfer money online. If in case you are facing the Cash App Transfer Failed problem. You just contact us via call, our expert techniques trying to resolve your issue or you can go through our website and get rid of your issue instantly.

jony said...


Nowadays people are switching to modern ways of getting entertained. They subscribe to different streaming services such as Netflix, Hulu, and more. One such streaming service among many others is Amazon Prime. This service not only gives you the eligibility to stream different videos but also lets you use many other features that come along with it. And, all of this can be done by getting and redeeming amazon.com/mytv

amazon.com/mytv
amazon.com/mytv enter code
Amazon com mytv

CGColors INC said...

Thank you for sharing the best information this blog is more helpful for me.
WordPress Plugin Development
WordPress Website Development Services
Magento Web Development Company
Magento to Shopify Migration

http://zdz-lodz.pl said...

Bardzo fajny sklep internetowy z lutownicami super ceny
Najlepszy sklep super asortyment oraz super ceny
Lutownica transformatorowa
Lutownica transformatorowa
Lutownica transformatorowa
Lutownica transformatorowa

Unknown said...

Connect with the best infrastructure company that can provide you the best home at the best location. We can be the right choice for you. Call us and book now. luxury apartments in Noida extension

Gaurav's Blog said...

Thank you admin for sharing this information with us. I really like it. It really helps me. Keep uploading these types of information.
Web Designing Company in London

Steadfast services said...

Are you looking for the best provider of Immigration Services in Dubai? If yes then connect with Steadfast service in Dubai, UAE.

Cssfounder said...

Here is the best offer for phone insurance at the affordable price
Ipad insurance plan

Akash Kanaujiya said...

Contact us if you want to grow your business through a website. We are the best website design company that provides services in this digital world, visit here to contact us.
Website design company Gdansk

Css Founder PVT. LTD. Web Design said...

Thankyou for sharing the data which is beneficial for me and others likewise to see Website design company in Kozhikode

Akash Kanaujiya said...

Before we start designing your site, we will carry out a competitive design of your sector Website design company. For any type of web service, contact us
Website design company Lixor

Prime IT Solution said...

Welcome to Prime IT Solution
Prime IT Solution is the software company that provide web solution to your Business site. We also provide mobile App development service. Prime IT Solution has a team of SEO and Digital Marketing expert that can take your business to next level.
Welcome to Dynamic Website Design Services
Websites should not only attract attention. Dynamic Web Design Services are meant to engage and attract users, communicate your brand, and increase awareness about products and services. To find the best solution for your needs, we will put great emphasis on your business's needs and help you build customer trust.

Rio Resort Lansdowne said...

Thanks for sharing such Nice and amazing blog. Riverside Resorts in Lansdowne

Vedasrivastu said...

I got something valuable information from your blog. Thanks for posting it!
Vastu consultant in Dubai

dubai for travel said...

nice blog good stuff! dubai tourism travel

dubai for travel said...

nice thoughts and details! dubai travel emirates

https://runwaybusrental.com/ said...

Nice one. I think I should try this. Keep posting
from : 30 seater bus

https://cheapdubaivisa.ae/ said...


Such a great post, Thanks for sharing us
from : entry visa

accepthealthcare said...

“I believe health care is a civil right.” Patient Care Services in Ambala

Sarita Nursing Bureau said...

You are never too old to set another goal or to dream a new dream. Nursing Care at Home in Greater Noida

Unknown said...


it is so informative keep posting interesting posts
rent a car bahria town lahore

7 Hotel Hills and Resorts | BlogSpot said...

Thanks for sharing. A memorable stay in Lansdowne. Resorts in Lansdowne

Bus rental Dubai said...

thanks for sharing thats amazing information bus rental Dubai

cssfoundergurgaon said...

When it comes to website designing companies in India, CSS Founders is undoubtedly the best in the business. With a strong reputation for providing exceptional websites that are both visually appealing and highly functional, it has established itself as a leader in the industry.

Saudi e-visa said...

If you need help with your "Saudi Arabia Visa apply online," I highly recommend visiting the website of visits visa. We offer a variety of services, including visa assistance, visa processing, and visa tracking. Our team of experts is knowledgeable and experienced, and they can help you to make sure that your visa application is complete and accurate.

Vishal Tomar said...

Are you planning a trip to India and need a visa? Look no further, as we offer a seamless and hassle-free online visa application process. At Visit Visa, we understand the importance of a seamless visa application experience, and we aim to make the process as simple as possible for travelers. In this blog, we will take you through the step-by-step process of applying for an India Visa online, highlighting the main requirements and documents required.

India Visa said...

Another reason for visa rejection could be that the eligibility criteria still need to be met. Sometimes it's typical to meet your specific eligible requirements for what type of visa you are applying for. India Visa can help you to get your eligible criteria for a visa.